Farmers Insurance Premier Agency · Established Owatonna, MN

A family name.
A personal promise.

A multi-state agency carrying a father's work forward — comprehensive coverage designed for families and business owners across Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa, Michigan, and Arizona.

0 Families Protected
0 States Served
0 Carriers Represented
A+ Farmers Premier
The William Tuttle Agency team at our Owatonna office
Plate I. The William Tuttle Agency team — Owatonna, Minnesota
Inside the Agency

Real people. Real answers.

Behind every policy is a licensed professional who answers the phone, knows your name, and treats your coverage like it matters — because it does.

Our agency operates on a simple premise: insurance is a relationship business. We invest the time to understand your circumstances, advise without pressure, and remain available long after the policy is bound.

Coverage

Every line you need, under one roof.

Farmers Insurance is our primary carrier, complemented by appointments with more than twenty additional companies for hard-to-place and specialty risks. Personal, commercial, and recreational — placed with intention.

How It Works

A considered path to coverage.

Three steps. No high-pressure tactics. No automated dialing. By the time we present a quote, you will already understand why.

01

A conversation

Fifteen minutes on the phone — your assets, your dependents, your priorities. No pitch. Just listening, and the right questions.

02

Analysis & optimization

Your risk profile, eligible discounts, bundling opportunities, and coverage gaps — reviewed across twenty-plus carriers.

03

Coverage, presented

A line-by-line walkthrough. Every question answered. Bound the same day when you are ready. Annual reviews for the life of the relationship.

Leadership

The people behind your policy.

A senior agency staffed by people who know your name — and answer the phone. Meet the full team →

W
William Tuttle
Owner & CEO

Second-generation agent carrying his father's work forward. Born and raised in Ellendale, Minnesota.

P
Peyton Curtis
Director of Operations

Runs the agency floor — workflow, producer support, and the systems that keep every client's policy on track.

J
Jessica Tuttle
Head of Customer Satisfaction

The voice clients hear most. Service, advocacy, and the relentless follow-through that defines our agency.

G
Gavin
Licensed Sales Agent

Multi-line specialist with a sharp eye for the gaps prior agents have missed.

Carriers

One agency. Twenty-plus carriers.

We lead with Farmers because we believe in the products and the company that stands behind them. When a risk requires a different home, our extended carrier roster ensures it has one.

Farmers Bristol West Foremost Progressive Safeco Travelers National General Tapco Pets Best Hagerty JC Taylor Jewelers Mutual CAT Coverage Steadily ErgoNext American Home Shield BTIS AmTrust RLI + more
Our Clients

Quiet work. Loud results.

A few words from the families and business owners we serve. Read more on Google →

Will identified $1,800 in annual savings and three coverage gaps our previous broker never flagged. A night-and-day difference in service.

Sarah & Jon M. · Home + Auto · Owatonna

Pipe burst at 2 a.m. The team had me on the phone within five minutes and walked me through the entire claim from a hotel room.

Ramon C. · Homeowner · Rochester

As a business owner I needed someone who understood more than a checklist. They built a program that fits how I actually operate.

Lena K. · Business + Auto · Mankato
Ready When You Are

Request your quote in minutes.

A complimentary, no-pressure consultation. Most families uncover meaningful savings — and every client leaves with clarity on what they are actually covered for.

Request a Quote (507) 451-1168