Request a QuoteCall (507) 451-1168
Coverage
Business
Service Area
Agency

About William Tuttle Agency, Owatonna, MN

Carrying the work forward.

A family agency headquartered in Owatonna, Minnesota, serving more than two thousand families and business owners across Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa, Michigan and Arizona.

Who is the William Tuttle Agency? We are a second-generation family insurance agency at 121 W Broadway St in downtown Owatonna, Minnesota, led by owner and CEO Will Tuttle. A Farmers Insurance Premier Agency with appointments across 20+ brokerage carriers, our team of fourteen protects 2,000+ families and business owners and is licensed in Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa, Michigan, and Arizona. Call (507) 451-1168 or request a quote.

William Tuttle, Owner and CEO of the William Tuttle Agency
W
Owner & CEO
Will Tuttle
MN License #40896974 · NPN #21006963
My Story

I grew up in Ellendale, a small town in southern Minnesota. A place that small teaches you a few things early: show up for people, do what you say you will do, and keep your word. That is still how I try to run this agency.

I went to school at NRHEG, where I ran track and played basketball. My father was in the insurance business, and I grew up watching how he worked. He took the job personally and took care of the people he served, and when I got into the business, I went to work alongside him.

My father has since passed away, and much of what he built came to me. Today I run the William Tuttle Agency out of our office in Owatonna. My team and I look after families and business owners across Minnesota and Wisconsin, and in Iowa, Michigan, and Arizona when a client needs us there. We are a Farmers Premier Agency, but more than that, we are local. You will find us at the Chamber, at Big Brothers Big Sisters, and at the youth ball games around town.

I am proud to carry my father's name on the door, and I do not take it lightly. If you want an agent who will pick up the phone and give you a straight answer, let us talk.

Will Tuttle Owner & CEO · William Tuttle Agency · Tuttle Family LLC
Our Story

The family story behind the name.

Thad Tuttle founded this agency in 2023; his son Will leads it today. Where the name on the door comes from, and what it still means, is a story of its own.

Read our story
The Team

Meet the people behind your policy.

When you call our office, you reach a name, not a queue. Fourteen professionals organized around how we actually serve clients: leadership, licensed sales, business development, and client service.

The William Tuttle Agency team inside our Owatonna office
In the office 121 W Broadway St · Owatonna, Minnesota

Leadership

Three
William Tuttle W
William Tuttle
Owner & CEO
MN License #40896974

Second-generation agent and an NRHEG grad, leading the agency his father founded in 2023.

Peyton Curtis P
Peyton Curtis
Director of Agency Operations
MN License #40962886

Keeps the agency running day to day, from workflow and producer support to the systems behind every client interaction.

Jessica Tuttle J
Jessica Tuttle
Head of Customer Satisfaction
MN License #40878216

Looks after the client experience, from your first call through every yearly review.

Licensed Sales

Seven
Gavin Briggs G
Gavin Briggs
Licensed Sales Agent
MN License #41027124

A multi-line agent with a good eye for the coverage gaps other agents miss. He will tell you straight what a policy does and does not cover.

J
Jose Amaya
Licensed Sales Agent
MN License #40973439

Works with families throughout the agency, and helps clients in both English and Spanish.

J
Jami Wick
Licensed Sales Agent
MN License #40963323

Patient and easy to talk to, especially on a first call. A lot of clients ask for her by name when they add a second policy.

E
Emmit Culver
Licensed Sales Agent
MN License #40859063

A licensed multi-line agent who walks clients through auto, home, and life coverage in plain English.

Justin Beauvais J
Justin Beauvais
Licensed Sales Agent
MN License #41057825

Helps families and business owners compare real options across our carriers and size the coverage to what they own.

Mia Miranda M
Mia Miranda
Licensed Sales Agent
MN License #41048193

Licensed across our personal lines and focused on getting people an accurate quote with a clear explanation the first time.

Wyatt Tuttle W
Wyatt Tuttle
Licensed Sales Agent
MN License #41061041

The third Tuttle on the team. He brings the same care to the work that the rest of the family does.

Business Development

One
Parker Bunn P
Parker Bunn
Sales Development Representative
MN License #40931125

Often the first person you will talk to. He walks new clients through what their coverage actually does, with no pressure and no script.

Client Service

Two
Vanessa Peterson V
Vanessa Peterson
Service Representative
MN License #41001238

Handles endorsements, billing, and the day-to-day details that keep your policy on track.

Lynda Virgin L
Lynda Virgin
Service Representative
MN License #1007948

Decades of experience and a steady hand on the most complicated household policies. She is the one in the office who remembers how it all works.

Marketing & Morale

Two
Levin Kitzer L
Levin Kitzer
Social Media Manager
MN License #41013512

Runs the agency’s social media — the posts, the photos, and the day-to-day voice people see between conversations.

Daisy D
Daisy
Office Dog

Greets everyone at the door, supervises from the rug, and has never once missed a treat. The only member of the team without a license.

Questions

Answers, up front.

Who owns the William Tuttle Agency?

Will Tuttle, a second-generation agent born and raised in Ellendale, Minnesota, owns and leads the agency. His father, Thad Tuttle, founded it in 2023; Thad passed away in February 2026, and Will carries the work forward. The legal entity is Tuttle Family LLC, and the team works out of 121 W Broadway St in downtown Owatonna.

Is the William Tuttle Agency part of Farmers Insurance?

Yes. William Tuttle Agency is a Farmers Insurance Premier Agency, and Farmers is our primary carrier. We also hold appointments with 20+ brokerage carriers, so one conversation can compare several real options rather than a single company's answer.

Where is your office, and when is it open?

Our office is at 121 W Broadway St, Owatonna, MN 55060, in downtown Owatonna. Hours are Monday through Friday, 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., with weekends by appointment. Call or text (507) 451-1168, or email wtuttle@farmersagent.com.

What states are you licensed in?

The agency is licensed in Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa, Michigan, and Arizona. Most of our clients are in southern Minnesota — Owatonna, Mankato, Faribault, Rochester, Albert Lea, Waseca, and Northfield — and we look after clients in our other licensed states when life takes them there. See our service area.

What types of insurance do you offer?

Auto, home, renters, life, business, umbrella, and boat, ATV, and motorcycle insurance, plus specialty lines such as pet, flood, jewelry, surety bonds, home warranty, classic auto, and landlord coverage. Farmers is our primary carrier, and we also quote through 20+ brokerage carriers. Browse every coverage line.